Vice President Kamala Harris blitzed the media this previous week with appearances on CBS’s 60 Minutes, ABC’s The View, The Late Present With Stephen Colbert on NBC, Howard Stern’s SiriusXM radio present, the podcast Name Her Daddy, and a city corridor with Univision. Return per week or so and we noticed her sit down for a one-on-one with MSNBC’s Stephanie Ruhle and seem on the sports activities podcast All The Smoke. That must calm the media malcontents who’ve insisted that she hasn’t sat for sufficient interviews, proper?
Fallacious. Politico opened the week with a widely panned assertion that, regardless of all these plans, Harris “remains to be avoiding the media.” It went on: “Let’s be actual right here: Most of those aren’t the kinds of interviews which are going to press her on points she might not need to speak about, at the same time as voters need extra specifics from Harris.”
Midweek, The New York Occasions dismissed the blitz with a condescending headline: “In Interviews, Kamala Harris Continues to Bob and Weave.” At first, the complaints centered on the prediction that Harris wouldn’t face powerful questioning; when actually she did, the criticism morphed: She didn’t reply straight sufficient.
The piece acknowledged that Harris was making an attempt to deal with voters’ issues that they don’t know sufficient about her—in a Occasions/Siena ballot final month, one in 4 voters mentioned they wanted to study extra about Harris, versus one in 10 who mentioned the identical factor about Donald Trump—however concluded: “Her verbal acrobatics could also be contributing to the impression that some voters have that they have no idea her or her coverage views very effectively. It has develop into a key weak spot as she rushes to sway tens of millions of undecided voters within the battleground states.”
Says who? The piece offers zero proof for this declare.
The idiocy of the massive media’s dismissing Harris’s interviewers will be refuted just by its huge and ranging audiences: Stern attracts an estimated 10 million listeners, and his viewers is three-quarters male. Alex Cooper’s Name Her Daddy is the number-one podcast on Spotify, and reaches 5 million listeners per week, overwhelmingly feminine. The View is the number-one daytime talk show, averaging 2.5 million viewers, most of them ladies. The Late Present with Stephen Colbert is the top-rated nighttime talk show, additionally averaging 2.5 million viewers. Harris’s 60 Minutes look drew 5.7 million voters, second solely to Monday Night time Soccer. No scores can be found but for the Univision City Corridor. It’s mathematically doubtful to easily add up the reveals’ viewership, since some folks watch a couple of, however let’s do it anyway: Greater than 25 million folks doubtlessly considered Harris’s media swing; tens of millions extra seemingly noticed the Univision particular.
However everyone knows amount is just not high quality. So how did Harris do? I watched all of her appearances, and graded them, from worst to greatest, beneath. Fast abstract: She rocked it, coping with powerful questions and humorous ones, showcasing coverage and empathy, unapologetically centering ladies, whereas not ignoring males. It’s no extra an assumption than the statements Harris’s big-media critics made about voters to conclude that these critics are primarily jealous that they’re now not the gatekeepers.
60 Minutes: Anchor Invoice Whitaker was out to show he was no pushover. He was aggressive, repeatedly interrupting Harris to get her to reply his questions. The interview was edgy, generally even disagreeable (Invoice, you’ll be able to smile sometimes with out being within the tank for Harris). But it surely was substantive, overlaying the Center East, Ukraine, the financial system, and taxes.
Harris acquired consideration for refusing to name Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu a “shut” ally. The Occasions cited that for instance of her evasiveness; I discovered it revealing that she wouldn’t use the phrase “shut.” As a substitute, she replied, “With all due respect, the higher query is do we’ve an necessary alliance between the American folks and the Israeli folks. And the reply to that query is sure.” I’m positive that acquired consideration in Jerusalem.
Like Stephanie Ruhle, Whitaker dogged Harris about how she’d pay for her $6,000 youngster tax credit score, her $25,000 first-time homebuyer subsidy, and a $50,000 tax write-off for start-up small companies. As she all the time does, she insisted that these applications would buoy the general financial system and thus increase tax revenues, and in addition repeated her promise to lift taxes on billionaires and large companies. Whitaker opined that Congress would by no means move these tax hikes, and Harris pushed again. “I disagree with you. There are many leaders in Congress who perceive and know that the Trump tax cuts blew up our federal deficit.” We’ll see about that. However to demand that Harris declare defeat on such a broadly widespread set of coverage priorities, as so many journalists do, appears wildly myopic.
Harris was certainly evasive when Whitaker pushed her about President Biden’s border insurance policies that allowed an increase within the variety of undocumented immigrants within the nation, preferring to emphasise how new insurance policies have stemmed the tide. For me, the alternate underscored one big problem for Harris: She is just not the president, and although reporters push her to distinguish and even distance herself from Biden, that ain’t gonna occur. To me, that’s simply fundamental politics; to others, it’s evasion.
Talking of evasion, Trump first accepted and then turned down an invite to do the present, reportedly as a result of he can be fact-checked.
Grade: Whitaker C, Harris B.
The Howard Stern Present: In case you might mix Invoice Whitaker with Stern, you’d have an amazing interviewer, one who pursued powerful questions however let Harris reply them, in addition to be herself: humorous, combative, unpredictable. (She’s a Components One fan? Who knew?)
However Stern instantly introduced that he supported Harris, and that he was loath to do any type of interview that will harm her probabilities. Howard, you’ve been at this longer than I’ve. However you harm her by taking any likelihood of powerful questions off the desk.
Certainly, it was a lovefest. Though the Occasions, once more, discovered fault with Harris’s reply to 1 substantive query: Would she put Liz Cheney, the Republican who has develop into an unlikely Harris supporter, in her cupboard? She didn’t reply. “I gotta win, Howard,” she mentioned. “I gotta win. I gotta win.” It was a wonderful reply. Initially, she’s proper. Second, she’s not going to announce what may be her most controversial cupboard choose upfront. Third: I’d guess cash that, whereas she’s pledged to place a Republican in her cupboard, she nonetheless isn’t positive who.
Standard
“swipe left beneath to view extra authors”Swipe →
Listeners needed to wait till the final 10 minutes to see the pair talk about what may be Harris’s boldest coverage proposal but: to broaden Medicare to cowl in-home take care of frail or disabled seniors. Stern kvelled over that; we discovered that his mom is 97. To me, it was a missed alternative to introduce Stern’s huge, male viewers to some breaking information, however possibly her time was higher used exhibiting that she’s a heat, humorous individual, and never a Communist childless cat girl.
Grade: Stern B-, Harris: B+
The View: Harris’s look on the present made headlines primarily due to her reply to a query about what she’d do differently from Biden. “There may be not a factor that involves thoughts,” she mentioned, other than naming a Republican to her cupboard. I don’t love that a part of her reply, however as I mentioned above, I don’t anticipate her to checklist her variations with Biden (and I’m positive she has some). Republicans pounced; who cares?
Harris hit Trump for his lies in regards to the Biden administration bungling its response to hurricanes Helene and Milton. “It’s profound, and it’s the peak of irresponsibility and, frankly, callousness,” she mentioned. “Lives are actually at stake proper now.”
She additionally took the chance to unveil, for this viewers of largely middle-aged ladies, her plan to get Medicare to cowl in-home care. “There are such a lot of folks in our nation who’re proper within the center,” she mentioned. “They’re caring for their youngsters, they usually’re caring for their getting old dad and mom, and it’s simply virtually unattainable to do all of it.” “Lastly,” Ana Navarro mentioned.
The View’s hosts had been heat, if not worshipful. Whoopi Goldberg endorsed Harris on the spot, and the pair locked eyes in a silent second that mentioned all the pieces in regards to the bond between the 2 Black ladies. It drove Trump (much more) loopy: He known as Goldberg “filthy soiled” at a rally that night time, labeling the panelists “actually dumb folks.”
That made one in every of Harris’s details. “He spends full time engaged in grievance about what has occurred to him,” she instructed the panel. “However what he doesn’t speak about is you. He doesn’t speak about what you want.”
Grade: Hosts: B+, Harris: B+
The Late Present With Stephen Colbert: This one was simply plain enjoyable—apart from a vigorous however pleasant alternate on Gaza. Colbert pressed her on why the administration has mentioned many occasions it’s “shut” to a deal, solely to nonetheless be with no deal. What does “shut” imply? he requested. She answered, a bit tersely: “It means we had numerous particulars labored out. A few of them weren’t.” The vp mentioned she’d met with hostage households in addition to “households of harmless Palestinian civilians who’ve been killed.” She added: “We should have a ceasefire and hostage deal as instantly as doable. This struggle has acquired to finish. It has to finish.” However she sounded pessimistic that it could finish anytime quickly.
Kudos to Colbert for pushing Harris on a query many people have needed extra substantive solutions to. He slipped coverage questions in with the jokes. Noting her plan for a billionaire tax, he mentioned she should know numerous billionaires coming from Northern California, seeming to softly rib the candidate who’s shut associates with Laurene Powell Jobs and different über-wealthy celebs. “So who’s your favourite billionaire?” She didn’t reply. “Oprah?” he prompted. No luck.
Harris acquired passionate speaking about Bob Woodward’s report that Trump secretly despatched Covid testing tools to Vladimir Putin in 2020, again when Individuals couldn’t get assessments. “I ask everybody right here and everybody who’s watching: do you keep in mind what these days had been like? You keep in mind how many individuals didn’t have assessments and had been making an attempt to scramble to get them?” A whole lot had been dying each day, she mentioned, unable to say goodbye to their households due to Covid restrictions in hospitals and nursing properties.
Visibly indignant, she went on. “And this man is giving Covid check kits to Vladimir Putin? Take into consideration what this implies on prime of him sending love letters to Kim Jong-un. He thinks, effectively, that’s his good friend. What in regards to the American folks? They need to be your first good friend.”
The funniest second was one you’ve in all probability already seen: Colbert confirmed Harris a photograph of her through the debate, when Trump was occurring about immigrants consuming pets. What had been you considering, he requested. “It’s household TV, proper?” she replied. “It begins with a W, there’s a letter between it, then the final letter’s F.” Then she broke into laughter.
They closed by ingesting beer collectively—Miller Excessive Life, in a can, “the champagne of beers,” she famous. It comes from Milwaukee, Colbert famous. within the “In order that covers Wisconsin,” he added, a key swing state. To be truthful, the vp took solely a chaste sip. The perfect half: The parents on Fox and Mates displayed faux outrage. “It simply doesn’t look good,” one mentioned.
Grade: Colbert A-, Harris: A
Name Her Daddy: Alex Cooper performed the most effective interview, in my opinion, one which mixed substance and emotion. She and Harris had a dialog that centered ladies—“the Daddy gang,” as Cooper calls her listeners, talks about intercourse (graphically), relationship, relationships, abortion rights, in addition to sexual abuse. However Cooper additionally requested exhausting questions on what Harris’s financial insurance policies will do for Gen X and millennials, who’re “disincentivized to vote as a result of politicians are basically like over-promising, under-delivering.”
They started with a transferring alternate about their moms; Cooper’s is a psychologist and Harris’s was a breast most cancers researcher. Each ladies instilled of their daughters a way of “company,” they agreed. However Harris shared a narrative I hadn’t heard earlier than. It’s value quoting at size:
“Once I was first operating [for attorney general], my mom was very sick with most cancers, and she or he in the end handed away. I might take her to the hospital, and I spent numerous time along with her and took care of her. So sooner or later we’re on the hospital and she or he’s within the mattress and she or he, you already know, she was at this section of her sickness the place she was actually simply actually drained.
“And so I’m sitting subsequent to her and she or he had her face turned within the different course. She was type of half sleeping. After which she leaned over to me and she or he mentioned, what’s occurring with the race? After which she leaned again over and I mentioned, effectively, mommy, they mentioned they’re going to kick my ass. At which level my mom turned her head, checked out me, and had the largest smile.
“Had the largest smile ever. That was my mom.”
Cooper requested what recommendation she’d give ladies struggling by means of sexual abuse—as Harris’s highschool greatest good friend did when the pair had been youngsters. “I’ve ladies write in being like, ‘I don’t know who to inform,’” Cooper defined. “‘I’m DMing you and I’m telling you as a result of [of the] the disgrace and the phobia. The place do I’m going from right here?’”
Harris answered intimately.
“So the very first thing that I might say to anybody going by means of it’s, inform somebody that you just belief. Don’t quietly endure.
“You’ve gotten finished nothing mistaken. You’ve gotten finished nothing mistaken and don’t let anybody persuade you you have got.
“Typically the abuser will inform her that if she tells, then one thing worse will occur. And that’s often mistaken.
“And know that there are those that need you to be secure and can need to defend you. However don’t silently endure.”
Cooper introduced up Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders’s tone-deaf assertion that youngsters preserve mothers humble, and since Harris doesn’t have organic youngsters, she has nothing to maintain her humble.
Harris nailed Sanders: “I don’t assume she understands that there are a complete lot of ladies out right here who, one, aren’t aspiring to be humble.
“Two, a complete lot of ladies out right here who’ve numerous love of their life, household of their life, and youngsters of their life. And I believe it’s actually necessary for ladies to raise one another up. You realize, I’ll inform you, Alex, one of many issues that I’ve actually loved about the place the dialogue has gone, one of many locations it’s gone, we’ve our household by blood, after which we’ve our household by love.
“And I’ve each. And I take into account it to be an actual blessing. And I’ve two stunning youngsters, Cole and Ella, who name me ‘Momala.’ We’ve a really trendy household. My husband’s ex-wife is a good friend of mine, you already know.”
The pair mentioned, intimately, the lethal toll Trump abortion bans are taking up ladies’s well being. Cooper, who was raised as a Catholic to consider abortion is a “sin,” notes that since Dobbs she has seen ladies understand you will be Catholic and pro-choice (most Catholics are). A few of her Southern Christian listeners, she mentioned, have instructed her that since Dobbs, they’ve realized “possibly I’m pro-choice as a result of I gained’t get an abortion due to my faith, however why ought to we management what another person needs to do?”
Perhaps essentially the most policy-rich but in addition private alternate got here when Cooper famous, “Nearly one in 4 Gen Z and millennials say they don’t need to have youngsters as a result of it’s too rattling costly. How are you going to assist younger folks not really feel left behind?”
That permit Harris lay out her $6,000 toddler tax credit score, her first-time homebuyer subsidies, her plan to make use of tax credit to get builders to construct extra properties. She additionally famous that the Biden administration has forgiven “pupil mortgage debt for tens of millions of individuals by this level, I believe over 5 million, together with doubling the quantity of pupil mortgage forgiveness for public servants like nurses and academics and firefighters.”
Cooper didn’t push Harris about Israel, or nag her about how she’ll pay for her applications. That can make some journalists dismiss the dialog as shallow. However younger ladies are amongst Harris’s most necessary voting blocs. They heard a uncommon hour of dialog centered on them, that includes essentially the most highly effective girl within the nation. That issues.
Grade: Cooper: A, Harris: A
Univision City Corridor: This one is hard to grade as a result of its format was so totally different from the remainder: an viewers, not simply an interviewer, asking Harris generally difficult questions related to their very own lives. The occasion mattered, maybe greater than the others, with Harris’s assist amongst Latinos flagging some, particularly amongst males. She promised to determine an “orderly and humane pathway to earned citizenship for hardworking folks,” and particularly for Dreamers, immigrants who got here right here as younger youngsters, who “shouldn’t need to reside in worry however ought to have the flexibility to be on a path to earn their citizenship.”
Harris additionally pitched the pocketbook proposals she bought on all of the reveals, from capping prescription drug prices to assist for first-time homebuyers, a beneficiant youngster tax credit score, and including in-home care to Medicare. “Whenever you simply raise up just a little little bit of the burden, folks thrive and all of us profit,” she mentioned. “And in order that’s how I take into consideration the financial system.”
The vp confronted the type of questions she wouldn’t get from mainstream interviewers. A Tampa resident, Ramiro Gonzalez, cited “rumors…that your administration didn’t do sufficient to reply to the final hurricane,” and requested Harris, “What would you particularly do, or your administration do, to assist us within the Tampa Bay space or the Central Florida space with this hurricane?” She acquired to decry the disinformation unfold by the best wing in regards to the federal emergency response. “I’ve to emphasize that this isn’t a time for folks to play politics,” she mentioned. She then itemized her briefings with state and native officers and her work to fight worth gouging within the aftermath of the disasters.
A 62-year-old girl named Martha Rodriguez mentioned she was homeless as a result of she suffers from lengthy Covid anf is unable to work, and has been ready three years for Social Safety to determine that she’s eligible for incapacity advantages. Harris instructed the girl she’d labored to get lengthy Covid categorized as a incapacity beneath the Individuals with Disabilities Act. She additionally touted her plans to ensure medical debt isn’t counted in opposition to your credit score rating, which is laudable however doesn’t sound like it could assist this girl. Rodriguez occurs to reside in Florida, and it was exhausting to not surprise if she’d have gotten extra assist in a state not run by Ron DeSantis.
The most moving exchange got here when a sobbing girl instructed Harris her mom died six weeks in the past with out reaching authorized standing. “You and I’ve one thing in frequent,” mentioned Ivett Castillo. “We each misplaced our mom.… My query for you is, what are your plans to assist that subgroup of immigrants who’ve been right here their entire lives, or most of them, and need to reside and die within the shadows?” Harris tried to consolation her.
“I’m so sorry for you,” she instructed Castillo. “Bear in mind your mom as she lived.” Harris admitted that “we do have a damaged immigration system.” However she reminded Castillo and the gang that “the primary invoice we supplied Congress” when she and Biden acquired into workplace “was a invoice to repair the immigration system, together with a complete, earned pathway to citizenship for hardworking folks. And it was not taken up.”
Harris then pivoted to tout the powerful immigration reform invoice crafted by conservative Senator James Lankford, which handed the Senate however not the Home, after Trump instructed Republicans to tank it “as a result of he would like to run on an issue as an alternative of fixing an issue.” It was an instance of the tightrope she’s strolling between emphasizing border safety and compassionate, humane insurance policies for the undocumented. But it surely additionally displays Democrats’ maybe belated realization that Latino voters aren’t a monolith; they embody advocates for much less restrictive immigration insurance policies but in addition individuals who work for the Border Patrol. She boasted of her work as a prosecutor going after gangs “from the Guadelajara cartel to the Sinaloa cartel.”
Then she returned to Castillo’s mom. “Let’s converse her title,” Harris mentioned. “Maria Dolores Figaroa,” the still-weeping girl instructed her. Harris sought out Castillo for a dialog after the occasion.
I can’t grade this one, however I assumed it was Harris’s greatest occasion of the week.
Can we depend on you?
Within the coming election, the destiny of our democracy and elementary civil rights are on the poll. The conservative architects of Challenge 2025 are scheming to institutionalize Donald Trump’s authoritarian imaginative and prescient throughout all ranges of presidency if he ought to win.
We’ve already seen occasions that fill us with each dread and cautious optimism—all through all of it, The Nation has been a bulwark in opposition to misinformation and an advocate for daring, principled views. Our devoted writers have sat down with Kamala Harris and Bernie Sanders for interviews, unpacked the shallow right-wing populist appeals of J.D. Vance, and debated the pathway for a Democratic victory in November.
Tales like these and the one you simply learn are important at this vital juncture in our nation’s historical past. Now greater than ever, we’d like clear-eyed and deeply reported unbiased journalism to make sense of the headlines and type truth from fiction. Donate right this moment and be a part of our 160-year legacy of talking reality to energy and uplifting the voices of grassroots advocates.
All through 2024 and what’s seemingly the defining election of our lifetimes, we’d like your assist to proceed publishing the insightful journalism you depend on.
Thanks,
The Editors of The Nation
Extra from The Nation
There merely isn’t any effort on the GOP aspect wherever near the scale and class of the Employee Energy canvas.
Democrats campaigning in blue and purple states ought to observe Schiff’s lead in making a problem of the GOP’s Trump cronyism.
All the issues with all the explanations some folks declare the Electoral School is an efficient factor.
A brand new examine reveals that states dominated by conservatives have markedly worse well being outcomes.
Each events are competing to see who can preserve propping up the identical previous failed myths about immigration.
He relished the limelight in 2016 and 2020. Now he’s refusing to debate and ducking interviews.
